The Psychology Behind Insider Stock Purchases
Image credit: Unsplash
"People don't buy stock; it gets sold to them. Don't ever forget that."
— Jordan Belfort, The Wolf of Wall Street⁴¹
"Watch insider buying—it's often a strong signal of confidence in the company's future."
— Leon Cooperman⁸
Those two lines book-end how pros read Form 4 filings. Belfort reminds us emotion drives the trade; Cooperman reminds us conviction drives the insider trade. When a CEO drops hard cash on the open market, they aren't buying a vacation home—they're making a statement.
Notice how virtually all insider transactions are red (sales) and blue (buys) are barely visible. This reflects the old Wall Street adage (famously noted by Peter Lynch): "Insiders might sell their shares for any number of reasons, but they buy them for only one: they think the price will rise"¹.
In other words, when executives or directors do dip into their own pockets, it's often interpreted as a strong vote of confidence in the company's future². Legal filings (SEC Forms 3/4/5) make all insider trades public, so savvy investors track these buys as potential bullish signals.
As Investopedia notes, large insider purchases are notable precisely because they signal management's optimism and conviction³. (Conversely, insider sales are far more common and have many benign motives, so they tend to carry less clear meaning⁴.)
The Human Element: Insiders Are Still Human
Investors should be cautious of hype – insiders are still human. Behavioral finance research finds that corporate insiders often fall prey to the same biases as the rest of us⁵.
For example, managers tend to anchor on past stock prices: they're unusually hesitant to buy when the stock is near a recent high, and more willing to buy after a big drop⁶.
Here's the reality check: A 2023 study across thousands of trades found only about 25% of insider purchases generate above-market returns⁷⁴². In other words, three times out of four, the "smart money" isn't so smart—or the timing stinks. This suggests that fear, overconfidence or other motives often play a role.
In short, an insider buy can be a bullish signal, but it's one piece of the puzzle, not a guarantee. Legendary investor Leon Cooperman summed it up simply: "Watch insider buying—it's often a strong signal of confidence in the company's future."⁸
Use these signals as idea starters – then dig deeper.
Why Insiders Buy: Key Motivations and Signals
When company leaders buy shares, they're sending a message. Often it's a multi-layered one. Common motives include:
Belief in Undervaluation
Insiders may feel the market is underpricing their stock. By buying now, they're essentially saying "I think this company is worth more than the market believes." In other words, they expect the stock to rebound.
As one analysis explains, insider purchases can mean executives see "a disconnect between the company's intrinsic value and its current market price," implying they expect the price to correct higher⁹.
Aligning Interests (Skin in the Game)
Buying stock forces executives to put their own money on the line, aligning their interests with outside shareholders. This demonstrates personal confidence in their strategy.
For example, one commentary notes that when leaders invest personal funds, it "demonstrates that they are personally invested in the company's success," which can build trust among all shareholders¹⁰. In practice, many companies even require their CEOs and directors to own a certain amount of stock for this reason¹¹.
Positive Insider Outlook
Insiders often have access (within the law) to non-public information about upcoming deals, products or plans. When they buy before such events, it's a sign they genuinely believe in positive developments ahead.
For instance, buying shares right before a major product launch or partnership might indicate management's confidence that these events will boost the business¹².
Restoring Market Confidence
A well-timed insider purchase can help soothe jittery investors. If the stock has been beaten down by bad news or market fear, an executive buying shares sends a reassuring signal: "We believe in the turnaround."
Practically, management sometimes clusters purchases to amplify this message. As one investment commentator explained, insiders may even make a clustered buy (several insiders buying together) specifically "to send a stronger signal to the market"¹³.
In effect, large insider buys can act like a morale boost, counteracting panic.
Compliance and Compensation Triggers
Sometimes buying happens for corporate-governance or personal-finance reasons. Many companies mandate that executives hold stock equal to multiple years of salary, so a CEO might make a planned purchase simply to meet that ownership guideline¹⁴.
Similarly, exercising stock options without selling can look like a purchase – in that case the exec is keeping shares because they expect the stock to rise¹⁵. These moves can coincide with a genuine bullish view or simply the mechanics of compensation, so investors should check the context.
Personal Tax and Diversification
Finally, personal financial planning can be a driver. An executive might buy company stock for tax reasons (e.g. to defer taxes or qualify for long-term capital gains) or to rebalance their portfolio¹⁶.
These purchases aren't necessarily tied to new optimism about the business; they can be routine financial decisions.
Each of these motives carries a different "emotional flavor." A buy from a CEO right after a downturn is often interpreted as bold confidence or contrarian optimism. A buy that merely satisfies an ownership rule is more mechanical.
The trick for investors is to read between the lines: who is buying, how much, and why.
Cognitive Biases and Emotional Factors
It's easy to forget that CEOs and directors – the very insiders themselves – are subject to the same psychology as other investors. In fact, behavioral finance studies find that insiders often exhibit biases.
One seminal paper shows that insiders anchor to round numbers: they tend to avoid buying near 52-week highs and prefer buying after large declines¹⁷. This "anchoring" behavior suggests emotions like fear of buying too high (loss aversion) and hope of catching a bottom can creep into insiders' decisions.
Furthermore, insiders may suffer from confirmation bias or cognitive dissonance. For example, a CEO who publicly champions a strategy might subconsciously avoid selling stock or may even buy more to stay consistent with past statements.
Overconfidence can also play a role: believing strongly in their inside view, executives might interpret ambiguous signals in the most positive light. Ironically, by the time an official Form 4 is filed, the insider may simply be locking in a position they had decided on earlier, not reacting to new information.
The Herding Effect
From the outside perspective, insider buys also trigger powerful group psychology. Seeing a well-known investor or CEO buy can create a mild herding effect. Other investors experience a bit of FOMO (Fear of Missing Out): "If the company's own boss is bullish enough to buy, I should buy too!"
The late motivational speaker Zig Ziglar captured this dynamic generally: "People don't buy for logical reasons. They buy for emotional reasons." In the case of insider trades, it often comes down to emotion – readers wanting to join the insider's confidence.
Academic research underscores caution. For instance, only about a quarter of insider purchases yield abnormal (above-market) returns¹⁸. And finance professor Nejat Seyhun found that stocks tend to outperform after insider buys but underperform after insider sells¹⁹, implying that net buying by insiders as a group does signal something real.
But the relatively low success rate (75% don't beat the market) suggests that timing, bias and noise dilute the effect²⁰.
Real-World Insider Buying Examples
Putting psychology into practice, let's look at a few real examples. These illustrate how insider motives and contexts vary:
Jamie Dimon's "Dimon Effect" (2009 & 2016)
The ultimate "putting money where the mouth is" moment. Jamie Dimon bought 500,000 JPM shares for $22.93 in January 2009⁴³ during the depths of the financial crisis. His $11M bet netted roughly $45M by 2016⁴⁴ — a masterclass in contrarian confidence when everyone else was running for the exits. Dimon wasn't just buying a stock; he was betting on his own bank's survival.
Tesla (May 2018)
Elon Musk purchased about 33,000 Tesla shares (~$9.8 million) via a 10b5-1 plan²¹. He had just boasted about inflicting pain on short-sellers on Twitter, and this large purchase was seen as backing his own bold statements.
It was a clear signal to investors that Musk still believed in Tesla's long-term prospects despite short-term skepticism²².
GameStop (Apr 2025)
GME remains fresh in investors' minds. New CEO Ryan Cohen bought 500,000 shares (~$10.7M) at roughly $21.55/share²³. He did this while GameStop's price had retraced from its meme-stock heights.
Cohen's buy was interpreted as a show of confidence in the turnaround plan; in fact, GME's stock jumped nearly 3% that day²⁴. Many traders view Cohen's actions as a classic "vote of confidence" in a beaten-down stock.
Zillow (Jul 2024)
When Zillow's founder stepped down as CEO, one of the earliest clues came from the other side of the table. Board member Jay Hoag quietly bought stock months before, at a time when Zillow's outlook looked shaky²⁵.
At the time of the buy, many questioned it, since the company was under pressure from real estate headwinds. But the purchase hinted that insiders foresaw a management change or strategic shift, which indeed came to pass²⁶.
This example shows how sometimes context (new CEO coming) can explain an insider buy that initially seems puzzling.
Sector Plays
Insider buys can also reflect industry-specific convictions. For example, MicroStrategy's CEO Phong Le purchased 6,000 shares ($510k) in early 2025²⁷, even as the stock was wildly swinging with Bitcoin's price. His buy underscored the company's all-in bet on crypto.
Similarly, Applied Materials' CEO Gary Dickerson splashed $6.9M on 50,000 shares⁴⁵ during a Trump tariff sell-off—his first major buy in a decade. By doing so, Dickerson signaled he believed AMAT's fundamentals would prevail despite short-term headwinds. The stock bounced 8% the following week²⁹.
Energy/Small Cap Example
More recently, Plug Power's CFO Paul Middleton spent $250k to buy 350,000 shares³⁰. Reports emphasized that this "demonstrates strong personal investment and confidence in Plug's hydrogen strategy"³¹.
In effect, the CFO was betting on the long-term clean-energy thesis despite ongoing losses.
Each case had its own story, but the common thread is that insiders bought when they personally believed the stock offered value or opportunity. As one analyst put it, these transactions are often "the primary motivation for insider purchases" – to signal confidence rather than chase a quick profit³².
In practice, investors have learned to treat such buys as leads rather than final answers.
Interpreting Insider Buys: Practical Takeaways
So, how should you, as an intermediate investor, interpret these insider buy signals? Here are some candid, practical points:
Focus on Size and Context
A tiny purchase by an insider (say, a few hundred dollars) is far less meaningful than a multimillion-dollar buy. Also consider who bought. A longtime director suddenly dumping his savings into company stock carries more weight than a junior officer spending a year's bonus.
In general, big buys by senior insiders grab attention for a reason.
Look for Clusters
One insider buying alone is helpful, but multiple insiders buying around the same time can be a stronger signal. A "cluster buy" suggests a coordinated show of confidence.
As one portfolio manager notes, clusters of purchases are often used to amplify the message to the market³³. If just one person buys while others are selling (or vice versa), that's worth noting.
Check for Trading Plans
Many insiders use Rule 10b5-1 trading plans to automate their buys and sells. Under 10b5-1, executives set up a schedule of trades when they aren't in possession of non-public information³⁴.
Here's what changed: Since 2023, officers must now wait up to 120 days after setting a trading plan before the first trade⁴⁶—an attempt to curb "I know the quarter, let me sell tomorrow" games. Plus, there's now a check-box on Form 4 where filers must declare if a trade was under a 10b5-1 plan.
A buy under such a plan isn't necessarily new confidence – it may just be a pre-scheduled transaction. If you see that 10b5-1 box ticked, treat the buy as less of a fresh conviction signal³⁵.
Consider Motive vs. Timing
Ask whether the buy is meant as a long-term statement or simply meeting obligations. For example, if a buy happens in a blackout period or immediately after a public announcement, it might be less about insight and more about timing (or even a bit of theatre).
Conversely, a buy just after an earnings miss, with no apparent news, could be a contrarian bet. Context matters.
Don't Ignore Basics
Insider buys should complement, not replace, your own analysis. An insider purchase doesn't override a poor balance sheet or dim industry outlook.
Always combine the insight of an insider buy with fundamentals like revenue trends, competitive position, and valuation. As one investor quipped, even if a CEO is bullish, "don't fight the Fed" – meaning broader market forces matter too.
Heed the Statistics
Remember that only about 25% of insider buys have historically beaten the market³⁶. That means three out of four times, following an insider buy wouldn't have been profitable on its own.
Why? Sometimes insiders are wrong, or outside investors pile in too late. Or purchases are too small. So stay level-headed – use insider buys as one tool in your toolkit, not a magic bullet.
Key Takeaways
In the end, insider stock purchases are as much about psychology and signaling as they are about raw financials. They reveal how insiders feel about the stock: whether they're greedy for more shares, aligned with you as a shareholder, or just following corporate policy.
As legendary investor Ray Dalio reminds us, markets are driven by both fundamentals and psychology. Insider buys are a perfect example of this mix.
So take their cues, but think for yourself. Insider buys can point you toward promising ideas, but they don't guarantee easy money. When you see an insider buy, ask: Who is buying? Why now? How much did they spend? And then do your homework.
"Watch insider buying — it's often a strong signal of confidence in the company's future," says Leon Cooperman³⁷. That's good advice to keep in mind. Just be aware that insiders, like all of us, have emotions and agendas.
As one study concluded, insiders are indeed "prone to behavioral biases, notwithstanding their access to private information"³⁸. In other words, don't treat an insider purchase as gospel. Use it as a tip to look deeper.
Understand the psychology behind the trade, and then make your own informed decision.
The Bottom Line (No Sugar-Coating): If a founder throws down millions of their own cash, they're talking with their wallet. But remember:
- Insiders are humans—anchored, overconfident, occasionally dead wrong⁴⁷
- Roughly 75% of insider buys fail to beat the index⁴²
- Your edge is adding fundamental research on top of these psychological breadcrumbs
Summary: Insider purchases can signal undervaluation, confidence, or alignment with shareholders, and are often seen as bullish. However, they can also stem from personal motives, compensation rules, or cognitive biases³⁹.
Always consider the context, check for trading plans, and combine insider cues with solid fundamental analysis⁴⁰. Or, as Peter Lynch put it: "Insiders might sell their shares for any number of reasons, but they buy them for only one: they think the price will rise."⁴⁸
Channel your inner Jamie Dimon: put your money where your analysis is, not where the hype leads you.
Disclaimer: This information is for educational purposes only and should not be considered investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Always consult with a qualified financial advisor before making investment decisions.
Sources
- When Insiders Buy Should Investors Join Them? - Investopedia
- Buy Stock With Insiders: How to Track Insider Buying - Investopedia
- What Investors Can Learn From Insider Trading - Investopedia
- Behavioral biases of informed traders: Evidence from insider trading on the 52-week high - RePEc
- 50 Top Trading Quotes of All Time - FinancHill
- Why CEOs and Founders Buy Their Own Stock and What It Means - KP Growth
- The Power of Insider Buys: Spotting Strong Signals from Key Executives - The Acquirer's Multiple
- Elon Musk Buys Almost $10M in Tesla Stock - Investopedia
- Insider Trading: 3 CEOs Recently Buying Shares - Nasdaq
- Plug Power CFO Paul Middleton Invests $250,000 in Company Stock - Nasdaq
- Rule 10b5-1 Definition, How It Works, SEC Requirements - Investopedia
- The Wolf of Wall Street Quotes - Goodreads
- Behavioral biases of informed traders: Evidence from insider trading - ScienceDirect
- Jamie Dimon's Crisis Purchases - WhaleWisdom Alpha
- Jamie Dimon's JPMorgan Chase Stock Purchases - Nasdaq
- Applied Materials CEO Gary Dickerson Stock Purchase - Barron's
- Updated Rule 10b5-1 Requirements - Skadden
- Peter Lynch Quote on Insider Trading - MarketBeat